These guys are hacks, just like city lad.
There is really only one way to solve this debate. Someone needs to get me one of each car to drive for a month (not sure I can collect enough data in a month, maybe 2-3 months per car).
After I'm done with 2-3 months per car, I'll compile my notes. I'll probably need to go back and drive all 3 a bit more to collect some more data. Then I will post the my all inclusive comparison to all three cars and declare the P1 the winner.
Also, for whomever is getting me the cars, to give Porsche a fair chance it sounds like we should opt for a color other than silver.
The things I do for the board in the name of science...